Book Now(305) 377-8004
Call Book Now
Home › Compare › Root canal vs extraction

Root canal or pull the tooth?

When a tooth hurts, pulling it sounds simple. Most of the time, saving it is the better deal.

Hallway at Brickell Dental & Aesthetics with the logo mirror and marble counter
Short answerA root canal removes the infected nerve and keeps your tooth. An extraction removes the tooth, and the gap then needs an implant or bridge. If the tooth can be saved, a root canal is almost always cheaper, faster and better in the long run.

Side by side

Root canalExtraction
What happensNerve removed, tooth sealed, crown on topTooth removed
Pain afterPain goes awaySore for a few days
Your toothYou keep itGone
What comes nextA crownAn implant or bridge to fill the gap
VisitsOne or two, plus the crownOne, plus the implant later
Total cost over timeLowerHigher, once you replace the tooth

Pick root canal if…

  • The tooth is cracked or decayed but the root is sound
  • You want to keep your own tooth
  • You want the lower total cost

Root canal

Pick extraction if…

  • The tooth is broken below the gum
  • The root is cracked
  • Gum disease has made it loose
  • You will replace it with an implant right away

Extraction

The thing people forget

An empty space is not free. The teeth next to it drift. The bone shrinks. Chewing shifts to the other side. Within a few years, the gap needs an implant, which costs more than the root canal and crown would have.

When we do pull it

Some teeth cannot be saved. Broken below the gum. Cracked through the root. Too loose from gum disease. Then we take it out gently, add a small graft, and plan the implant the same day.

Common questions

Ask us directly
Does a root canal hurt?

No. With modern numbing it feels like a long filling. The toothache is what goes away.

Can I leave the gap after pulling?

You can, but the neighbor teeth drift and the bone shrinks. It gets harder and more expensive to fix later.

How do I know if the tooth can be saved?

An X-ray tells us. We show it to you and explain the choice.

Want a second opinion?

Book a visit. We show you both options on your own photos.